This is usually one of my favorite columns to write, mostly because of the (often faulty) narratives surrounding the quarterback position. So many internal biases go into these sorts of rankings (including my own), so I figured that one more opinion piece can't hurt. Unlike some, I'm going to take my lumps for past misses on these rankings; if a player was ranked in the four previous (2022, 2023, 2024 or 2025) versions of this column, that ranking will be presented so you can

QB accuracy has many definitions across the NFL and what people use to define it will vary greatly. Myself, I took a couple of measurments from the good people at stathead.com to see if I could find a meaningful yet simple metric. I looked at three of their advanced stats: On Target Throw % (pretty simple to grasp, the percentage of times a QB hits his target), Good Throw % (basically, the percentage of throws that aren't Bad Throws by their definition) and Intended Air Yards

A few days ago we asked the question, "Who is Jalen Hurts?". In that piece I briefly mentioned a metric that I called "comeback success rate" that attempted to compare the number of times a QB had led his team to a 4th quarter comeback (or had led his team on a game winning drive) to the number of opportunities that this player had to do this. This was done by adding the number of comebacks attributed to the QB to the number of losses to estimate how often the player was trai